|
- TO: Det. Armstrong
- FROM: L. Evans, YCCSS
-
- RE: Initial report: Dylan Tull
-
- Det. Armstrong,
-
- At your request, I'm writing to give you some
preliminary information
- with regards to Dylan Tull and his mother, Bonnie
Tull. A full report
- with follow-up information will follow this memo.
-
- I met briefly with Mrs. Tull on July 28, and also met
with Dylan at that
- time. I had a follow-up meeting with Dylan at his
grandmother's house in
- XXXXXXXXX on Friday, Aug. 1. During these meetings my
immediate goals
- were to establish the circumstances of the boy's
interaction with the
- victim, Purity Knight, and also to ascertain whether
the boy and/or his
- mother needed immediate counseling and whether the
boy was being
- criminally neglected.
-
- 1. Circumstances of interaction with victim
-
- From my conversations with the Tulls I have been able
to construct the
- following timeline of events.
-
- Dylan first interacted with the victim on the morning
of Saturday, May
- 31, while exploring in the woods. Mrs. Tull confirmed
that she had worked
- until 2 a.m. that morning and slept until about noon.
Dylan has his own
- keys and has been independently running errands and
going places for the
- past several months, so his leaving the house on his
own is not unusual
- behavior for him. When he encountered the victim,
Dylan said they talked
- and the victim asked Dylan to come back with pens and
paper.
-
- Dylan visited the victim a second time on the morning
of Monday, June 2.
- Mrs. Tull was working the breakfast shift that day.
He did bring the
- requested items, and the victim wrote a note and
asked Dylan to deliver
- it to the police. The victim also asked Dylan to
bring food on his next
- visit. On his way back from the site, Dylan
encountered a man who said he
- would deliver the note for Dylan. Dylan gave the note
to the stranger and
- returned home without incident.
-
- Dylan visited the site a third and final time on
Wednesday, June 4. As
- with the previous visit, Mrs. Tull was working that
morning. Dylan
- brought the victim an apple and an orange. He also
brought with him a new
- tape recorder, which he had bought with allowance
money at the Salvation
- Army and fixed by himself. He talked with the victim
and made an audio
- tape.
-
- On Thursday, June 5, Dylan went to his grandmother's
house and did not
- see the victim alive again. He revisited the site on
Monday, June 9, on
- the morning, and was spotted on the scene by Mr.
Archer.
-
- Dylan learned that the victim had indeed died when he
tried to convince a
- friend, Luke Hawthorne, to visit the site the
following week. Luke told
- Dylan the woods were haunted by "the dead girl."
Dylan did not confide
- his knowledge of the victim with Luke or anyone and
made no further
- attempts to visit the site.
-
- 2. Assessment of need for counseling
-
- Bonnie Tull has been attending sporadic counseling
sessions through the
- MHD. In our conversation she said "I know I need
help, it's just a matter
- of having time to get it;" this incident seems to
have spurred her to
- take further action. My initial impression was that
she is depressive and
- would benefit from more intensive therapy, possibly
accompanied by
- medication. She could also benefit from basic
counseling on parenting
- strategies and stress management. As a follow-up, I
plan to contact Mrs.
- Tull's counselor at the MHD and obtain further
details as well as contact
- several agencies that might be able to help Mrs.
Tull.
-
- Dylan Tull has never been referred for counseling,
although a number of
- his teachers referred to him as "quiet." After
speaking with him for
- several hours, my impression was that he is extremely
withdrawn and has
- some anti-social tendencies. Both traits are most
likely a product of his
- somewhat isolated environment and the independence
which has been
- necessary for him to survive. Dylan is very
intelligent and imaginative
- and does not exhibit signs of chronic depression or
anxiety, although in
- discussing his relationship with the victim he became
agitated and upset
- on several occasions. Aside from some short-term
post-trauma counseling I
- believe Dylan does not need further therapy, unless
he and his mother
- were to undertake some sessions together to learn
more about each other
- and how they can better interact.
-
- 3. Assessment of possible criminal neglect
-
- I do not believe Bonnie Tull has criminally neglected
Dylan, and Dylan
- should neither be relocated to his father's residence
in Florida nor be
- placed into foster care. Dylan's grandmother
frequently steps in whenever
- Bonnie feels most unable to assume the
responsibilities of motherhood,
- and I believe this arrangement is satisfactory for
the present. However,
- a reconsideration of Mrs. Tull's custody of Dylan may
be appropriate in
- the event that she fails to seek the counseling
outlined above.
-
- A full report will follow within the week.
-
- [signed]
- Lori
|